Banshees of Inisherin: even better if you know the Irish history behind it

It doesn’t take a PhD in Irish history – thank goodness, because I don’t have one – to know it Inisherin from Inisherin Not just a crazy, cheerful tale of Irish pomp. He. She he is That, since writer and director Martin McDonagh (from in Bruges And the Three billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri) Unable to make out a boring story. But there is more than what is on the surface.

Inisherin from Inisherin It plays like a very funny tale or folk tale, the story of two lifelong friends, Pádraic (Colin Farrell) and Colm (Brendan Gleeson). The two men live on a remote island off the Irish coast, which is sparsely populated by a group of eccentrics who have known each other forever and are unlikely to ever leave. The only occupant who aspires to get off the island is Padrick’s sister, Siobhan (Kerry Condon), who is sick to death of everyone, especially men, who, she says, “are all boring.”

Well, maybe not All Boring. One day at the pub, Padrick discovers that Colm is no longer his friend. The reason for the break is out of reach for Pádraic, and even a bit out of reach for Colm, who can’t handle his friend anymore. But when Padrick could not accept Colm’s decision, Colm proceeded to explain his intentions in the most vague way possible.

A man sitting in a room.  Other peers out the window.

Gleeson and Farrell V Inisherin from Inisherin.
Scout Pictures

McDonagh (Irish, but raised in London) is a playwright by heart and by trade, he thrives on this kind of setting: a heavily controlled world of eccentrics, a hothouse of quarrels, inside jokes, little meat and grudges that last so long that people hardly remember where they come from. they started. It makes for very entertaining storytelling, and it’s at its best in this distinctly Irish setting. Gleeson and Farrell reunite, whose pairing of singles led to a gothic crime comedy in Bruges Don’t forget, it was the right choice. They’re great in roles, Gleeson as a grumpy, tired world and naive Pharrell who seems to be missing a few screws.

But if you don’t find out what’s going on in the background Inisherin from InisherinIt then plays out as a strange tale told late into the night over a few pints. The movie really expands when you look at the background.

Because just across the road, across the water from Inisherin, there are visible explosions on the coast. The characters occasionally comment on them, musing about the fight taking place there, a struggle they hope and believe will end soon. Never mind – don’t touch them here on the island, it’s Colm and Padrick’s break that grabs everyone’s attention.

It is assumed that this fighting was in fact part of the Irish Civil War. The film is set in the year 1923, at a time when the conflict has been raging for nearly a year. It is part of the long history of conflict and violence in Ireland, and has mostly to do with vastly divergent views of British rule of the island. The Civil War began after the Irish War of Independence, creating Ireland as a free country that would nonetheless remain part of the British Commonwealth (in other words more like Canada than Scotland). Some who fought for independence with the Irish Republican Army supported the treaty that created the Free State; Others strongly opposed itbelieving that Ireland should be completely free of British interference.

The result was a bloody war in which the men who fought on the same side were now fighting each other, which lasted from June 1922 to May 1923. Watch Inisherin from Inisherin With this in mind, you can start to see what McDonagh is doing. The estrangement between Colm and Padrick operates on its own terms, but it’s also a stunningly violent battle between men who are basically brothers, one that makes sense at that and yet is heartbreaking precisely because of the depth of history between them. It’s the struggle in a microcosm.

Two men facing the water, away from the camera.  One looks at the other.

Gleeson and Farrell look across the water in Inisherin from Inisherin.
Scout Pictures

The title “rut” (and the song Colm composes all the time) is also important. They are descended from Irish folklore: female spirits scream, wail and grieve, indicating that a family member will soon die. in Inisherin from InisherinThere is no literal free, but that is clearly the role of Mrs. McCormick, the old pipe-smoking woman that Padrick shuns like the plague, in the village. Her dark vows indicate that death is looming – literally, on the horizon they can see.

In the end, the characters think that the conflict across the road seems to be ebbing, and it seems that the conflict over Inisherin may be too, in the darkest of manners. But this dialogue is meant to take into account the bitter irony – or perhaps the darkest comedy, which are two sides of the same coin in Ireland. For we know, 100 years later, that conflict has not abated in Ireland, even if there is a fragile peace in the Republic. More fighting would take place, much of it in Northern Ireland (now part of the United Kingdom), specifically during the turmoil that lasted from the 1960s to the 1990s. More blood will be shed, and conflicts will divide Irish society for generations.

which it offers Inisherin from Inisherin Comedy, undoubtedly, and often quite funny – with its tragic backbone. Friend over friend, brother over brother, lost love, and grudges break the fabric of society; It is all contained in this little tale. And the torment of the prediction of grief stands in the background, screaming and grieving over everything.

Inisherin from Inisherin Opens in theaters October 21.

Leave a Comment